Blog

ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini rarely agree on local businesses

OOO Works ·

More people now ask an AI assistant, not a search engine, for “a good plumber near me”. So we asked three of them the same 48 questions and wrote down who they recommended and which websites they used to decide.

The short version: the three assistants rarely agreed. Of the 1,321 businesses they named, only 11% were named by more than one assistant. And they lean on other websites to choose: 92% of answers cited at least one directory, review platform or “best of” list. A business that isn’t on the sites the assistants read for its trade and country has little chance of being named.

What we asked

Six kinds of local business (plumber, electrician, dentist, accountant, hair salon and wedding photographer) in eight cities: New York, Austin, London, Manchester, Toronto, Sydney, Dublin and Auckland. Each question read like this:

I’m looking for a good plumber in Manchester, United Kingdom. Which ones would you recommend? Put each business name in bold.

We asked on 19 November 2026, with web search on, once per question:

That’s 144 answers. Every one is in the data file (CSV): the businesses named and the sites cited, per assistant, city and trade.

Finding 1: they rarely name the same businesses

Assistant Businesses named per answer Sites cited per answer
ChatGPT 4.0 4.2
Claude 8.5 6.9
Gemini 18.5 8.0

Across the 48 questions they named 1,321 different businesses. Only 11% were named by more than one assistant. In 27% of the questions, all three named at least one of the same businesses; in the rest, there was no business all three agreed on.

ChatGPT gave short lists, Gemini long ones. So being named by one assistant says little about the others. If you check whether AI recommends your business, check each one.

Finding 2: they decide from directories and lists

What the cited sites were:

Kind of site Share of all citations Answers citing at least one
Directories and review platforms (Checkatrade, Fresha, Angi, Trustpilot…) 32% 80%
A named business’s own website 27% 62%
“Best of” lists and articles 12% 47%
Government registers and professional bodies 2% 10%
Forums and social media 1% 3%
Other sites, not sorted 27% 74%

92% of answers cited at least one directory, review platform or list. The businesses’ own websites mattered too: 62% of answers linked to the website of a business they named. (That figure is a floor: we only counted a site when its address matched the business’s name.)

Reddit and social media hardly appeared: forums and social sites were 1% of citations.

Which sites the assistants read, by country and trade

The sites cited most often for each country and trade, counted by the number of answers that cited them. They differ a lot by country, which is why there’s no single list to be on.

Country Cited most often
United Kingdom Checkatrade (12 answers), Which? Trusted Traders (6), Hitched (4), MyBuilder (4)
United States Expertise.com (8), Angi (7), ConsumerAffairs (7), WeddingWire (6), Zola (5)
Canada HomeStars (4), WeddingWire.ca (3)
Australia Calso directory (5), ProductReview.com.au (4), Localsearch (3), Time Out (3)
Ireland Bark (5), Trustpilot (4), Checkatrade (3), Golden Pages (3)
New Zealand MoneyHub (15), Top5.nz (7), Builderscrack (4)
Trade Cited most often
Accountant Clutch (10), The Manifest (8), Bark (5), GoodFirms (5)
Dentist WhatClinic (6), Birdeye reviews (4), Dentist Locator (3)
Electrician Checkatrade (7), Angi (5), ConsumerAffairs (4), Which? Trusted Traders (4)
Hair salon Fresha (10), Time Out (5), Fashion Journal (4), Treatwell (3)
Plumber Checkatrade (8), Trustpilot UK (4), ConsumerAffairs (3), Expertise.com (3)
Wedding photographer Wezoree (9), WeddingWire (6), WPJA (5), Zola (5), Fearless Photographers (4)

These counts are small. Read them as “the assistants clearly use these sites”, not as a ranking.

Finding 3: ask again and you get a different list

A few hours after the first run we asked all 144 questions again, word for word, same assistants. For each assistant and question we compared the two lists of businesses.

Assistant Businesses from the first run named again
ChatGPT 36%
Claude 48%
Gemini 57%
All three 52%

So about half the businesses an assistant recommends one time aren’t in its answer the next time, for the same question. The sites they cite move less, but still move. On the second run, 86% of answers cited a directory, review platform or list (92% the first time).

This matters if you check whether AI recommends you: one check is a snapshot. Ask more than once, on different days, before deciding anything. Both runs are in the data files: second run (CSV).

Eight more cities: the same pattern

We then asked the same six trades in eight more cities: Chicago, Miami, Birmingham, Glasgow, Vancouver, Melbourne, Singapore and Cape Town (data (CSV)).

Country Cited most often in the new cities
United Kingdom (Birmingham, Glasgow) Checkatrade (8 answers), Which? Trusted Traders (7), TrustATrader (6), FreeIndex (4)
United States (Chicago, Miami) Angi (7), ConsumerAffairs (7), Expertise.com (7)
Singapore MissLobang (5), Vogue Singapore (5), TheBestSingapore (4), Honeycombers (3)
South Africa (Cape Town) Procompare (6), Bark (3), Fresha (3), WhatClinic (3)
Australia (Melbourne) Calso directory (4), ProductReview.com.au (4)
Canada (Vancouver) WeddingWire.ca (3)

In Singapore the assistants leaned on local lifestyle and “best of” sites more than on directories.

What this means for a local business

  1. Be on the directories the assistants read for your trade and country, with complete details and recent reviews. The tables above are a starting point; search your own trade and city in each assistant and look at what it cites.
  2. Keep your own website readable by AI crawlers. Six in ten answers linked a business’s own site. If your site blocks the crawlers, the assistants can’t quote it. Our free AI crawler check tells you in a minute; this guide explains the fixes.
  3. Check more than one assistant, more than once. They disagree with each other most of the time, and with themselves half the time, so one result tells you little. Our free AI answer check asks Gemini for you. How to track whether AI assistants mention your business shows how to do it by hand for free.

How we counted, and the limits

The code that asked the questions and counted the answers is part of the OOO Works visibility engine. If you use the data, please link to this page.

Check your own site. Our free AI crawler check shows, for ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Google's AI answers and Copilot, whether they can read your pages, and what to change if they can't.